The Mysterious Lever

Tuesday, August 1, 2017

Interacting with "The World"

We all strive to change the world around us. Sometimes, we sit down at a table and pretend we have more influence than we really do by interacting with an imaginary environment controlled only loosely by a set of agreeable rules. We want to see how, through our character's actions, we can change that made up world.

We play RPGs to find out what happens. That is why they almost always include some sort of random chance: fate is just another player in the world building sessions we indulge in. Fate is one way to make the world interesting. We use our actions, and those of fate, as an input to discover a world filled with mystery, intrigue, and adventure. The output of those actions, of course, is a world that has changed.


In Hostargo, I've put a heavy focus on how characters interact with the world. Their special abilities, roles, and even motivations are all driven by a need or want for change. This enables players to have a visible impact on the game world, rewarding them simply by the act of playing the game. The Cypher archetype, for example, interacts with the world through hacking cyberspace, enabling them to change the way physical machines work. The Socialite has a knack for manipulating the world's NPCs, instantly making the player feel power over those around them. For those with a more mystical side, the Daemon archetype gives the player power over light and the shadows it creates.

Hostargo stresses the need for interesting environments. Players want to use their abilities to shape the events, characters, and locations that surround them. Good adventure design is the key to a good game, and Hostargo aims to be the perfect toolbox for designing those adventures. Defining archetype abilities gives the GMs of Hostargo the ability to populate their adventures with environmental interaction opportunities. Once the environment is set, the rest is up to the players (including the ever-so-exciting fate)!

Characters interacting with the world around them is ultimately what every RPG is about. There are an infinite variety of flavors and styles of this input->output function, which is why there are so many RPGs. Hostargo is my flavor, and its archetypes are my style.

Monday, July 24, 2017

Giving Players Tools, Not Roles

Sitting down at a table with some of your friends, bullshitting around with a story, and making badass characters thrive is only a shallow perspective on what we actually want out of RPGs. That's a problem, because it's hard to pinpoint what makes the games we all remember so memorable.

The base design of any good game should always answer some core questions: what is this game about? What is it trying to accomplish? What is it trying to get the players to think, feel, and experience? For Hostargo (and RPGs like it), heroics is a possible answer. Awesomeness could be another. But really, playing an actual roleplaying "game", and not just participating in a storytelling experience, requires meaningful, interesting choices to be made by the players.

The key here is that the adventure, not the system, is the most important aspect for creating these interesting player decisions. What that means for system design is that a good system should simply exist to aid in the design of interesting adventures. That means it should facilitate the creation of the characters, plots, environments, and situations that the players will find themselves in.

A system that has things like "classes" and character progression should really aim to be a toolbox, not a means to an end. I've been doing this wrong lately while trying to think of what "roles" characters should play in Hostargo. I might even be so bold as to just scrap the idea of "roles" from "roleplaying" all together, in favor of giving players an interesting toolbox, and having any players in any scenario feel like a "good player" for solving the problems at hand with their customized toolset.

Of course, we want a focus on teamwork, and giving every player an equal opportunity to shine. So, we need to tread carefully with our classes. Give players the generalized tools that make their character both unique and useful, but don't shoe-horn them into such specialized roles that they don't have the freedom to overcome obstacles that aren't in their pre-defined "wheelhouse".

The games that fail in this regard are almost obviously too rigid in their designs. Games that use the combat-triforce of tank/heal/dps clearly shoe-horn their characters. That can be valid for a video game, or even a tactics/war tabletop game, but it doesn't lend itself well to merging story into the action. On the flip side, this idea can also result in an overwhelming sense of "sameness", as we saw in 4th edition D&D. It's technically a great game, and there's a lot of enjoyment to be had, but when everyone starts to feel like they can do everything just as well as everyone else, you loose the sense of "team" that really makes TRPGs a shared experience.

The games that implement this idea the best, in my opinion, are Powered-by-the-Apocalypse. Each character playbook gives players unique tweaks and abilities that make them feel special, but when it comes down to the wire, the system is there to resolve players' decisions, not give them a limited set of useful choices as a predefined "role". This is one of the reasons the "rules get triggered" idea is so brilliant. The players make choices, the rules come forward to resolve those choices, rather than the players making choices based on the rules.

Saturday, July 22, 2017

Brainstorming on Personas

Interactions with NPCs are some of the most enjoyable and memorable scenes in any role playing game. As many other games have described it, social interaction is one of the three pillars of roleplaying (along with Exploration and Combat). Characters who are connected to the world setting through NPCs are more alive, and therefore more enjoyable to play.

This holds true in some of the world's most famous RPGs. Not only do we like meeting some of our movie heroes in games like Star Wars or Firefly, but we also enjoy meeting new and interesting characters, which is why Bioware games like Baldur's Gate, KOTOR, Dragon Age, and Mass Effect have been such a huge success. From tabletop, we can definitely pick out adventures and campaigns where we met and interacted with incredible characters, such as Meepo from the Sunless Citadel.

There's been a few successful ways of tying characters into the world through NPCs.

Shadowrun takes the approach of specific connections which have a certain loyalty and usefulness ratings. These NPCs are fun because they "belong" to you, but are also not for certain going to be the answer you need at any given time. However, these NPCs are rarely fleshed out or much more than couple numbers on a piece of paper, so GM-Player interaction with them is limited at best.

The Burning Wheel, GURPs, and Mistborn are systems that have options for family members, close friends, or other NPCs built into your backstory. If explored, they can be very rewarding. But, this type of approach forces the GM to shoe-horn in NPCs where they might not otherwise belong. It also hogs the spotlight for certain characters whenever those NPCs are in the scene, meaning the GM has to balance everyone's NPCs.

Instead of these types of what I'd call "hard-coded" connections to the world, I want to take a more "loosely-coupled" approach. One of the neatest things about Bioware's video games is the different dialog options that appear based on your character's past choices, their public image, or even just what they're wearing. Playing off of this, I'd like to explore the possibility of giving players "personas", giving them 2-5 "persona points" at character creation:

-----

Personas
Personas are your character’s different faces to the world. Donning a persona can give you otherwise unavailable opportunities to interact with NPCs. These interactions can lead to special information or access to goods/services. Each persona has a “fame” level (1 persona point per fame upgrade) and a “defining feature”. This feature could be a gang tattoo, corprate signet ring, some secret gesture or phrase, or an article of clothing; anything obviously recognizable will do.


Level 1 Persona: Can be verified as belonging to the group.
Level 2 Persona: Commonly known as part of the group.
Level 3 Persona: Commonly known by those who have relations with the group.
Level 4 Persona: Commonly known in the region as associated with the group.
Level 5 Persona: Commonly known worldwide as associated with the group.

-----

I can see players taking on Personas of different corporate, gang, or political organizations. This type of thing would allow a player to play a movie-star or famous author without sacrificing any combat or other general 'usefulness' features. Really, it might just be that the shopkeeper is a big fan of your books, so he shows you his secret stash, or the club you need to infiltrate lets you in right away because of your street cred.

There are plenty of opportunities here, where players can inject their personas into the world at the time they see fit, and the GM can respond and create interactions accordingly, without having to plan ahead of time. What do you think? Any serious issues? Think you'd have fun with it?